By Blair Smith · April 7, 2026

🎧 Stream us on Apple Podcasts and Spotify!

There’s a moment every enthusiast hits—usually while scrolling classifieds late at night or justifying another “great deal”—when the question quietly creeps in: How many cars is too many?

Provided enough cash exists in the slush fund account to acquire them, the answer seems pretty clear - there is no such thing as too many!

More cars means more freedom, more variety, more joy! But as the collection grows, so do the trade-offs.

Let’s be honest: the argument for more cars is incredibly compelling.

This is the foundation of the entire hobby. Every car offers a different experience—the sound, the feel, the personality. A garage full of cars isn’t excess; it’s a menu of experiences!

One day it’s a canyon run, the next it’s a relaxed cruise and variety is the spice of enthusiast life.

No single car does everything perfectly. The dream is to assemble a lineup where each vehicle excels in its role:

The “needs” list is limitless and each addition fills a “gap.” Before long, the collection starts to feel logical—even necessary.

Unlike most consumer goods, enthusiast cars—especially those that have already taken their depreciation hit—can hold value surprisingly well.

Some even appreciate.

It becomes easier to justify a purchase when it feels less like spending and more like reallocating money into a tangible, enjoyable asset.

“Don’t worry honey, this Porsche 356 SC is the same as cash!”

There’s no dressing this up. The hunt, the negotiation, the first drive home—it’s a rush. Buying cars scratches an itch that never fully goes away.

For many enthusiasts, collecting isn’t just a hobby; it’s part of their identity.

But every additional car carries weight—literally and figuratively.

At some point, the cars start winning and everything else starts losing.

Bikes get pushed to the side. Storage disappears.

Daily life becomes a game of automotive Tetris.

What started as a dream garage can quietly become an impractical one.

Each car has needs: fluids, batteries, tires, registration, repairs.

Multiply that by several vehicles, and what used to be enjoyable wrenching or occasional upkeep turns into a constant to-do list.

Instead of excitement, you start to feel obligation—and sometimes even guilt.

We enthusiasts don’t want the upkeep of our cars slip after all.

Even if the cars hold value, that money is still locked away.

I think back to my college Econ classes and having the concept of opportunity cost beaten into my head – “what else could/should I be using that money on?!”

Insurance, maintenance, registration, etc. A large collection can look strong on paper but limit flexibility in real life.

I’ve always said that if I’m not regularly driving it….it has to go!

No matter how pretty they might be, garage queens don’t do much for me. I want to drive them.

The more cars you own, the less each one gets used.

That special machine you once couldn’t wait to drive can end up sitting for weeks—or months.

And when cars sit, they don’t just lose miles—they lose meaning. And oftentimes, become more needy.

The goal isn’t to stop collecting—it’s to collect intentionally.

A well-balanced garage isn’t defined by size, but by use. The “right number” of cars is the number you can:

For some, that number is three. For others, it’s ten. The difference isn’t passion—it’s capacity.

Some helpful questions to ask:

Does each car still feel special?

Does having this car around cause me any stress?

Am I itching to regularly grab the keys to that car?

If the answer starts to drift toward “not really,” it might be time to refine rather than expand.

Car collecting is one of the most rewarding forms of enthusiasm out there. It blends passion, nostalgia, engineering, and lifestyle into something deeply personal.

But like any great thing, it benefits from restraint.

Because in the end, it’s not about how many cars you own—it’s about how much joy you get from the ones you keep.

As for me? I’ve convinced myself that my perfect number is 3 – a daily, and two toys.

I currently have one too many….

I want to know, what's your perfect number? Would love the feedback!

— Blair Smith

📩 Don’t keep Full Throttle Talk a secret—share it with a friend, family member, or colleague. Let’s spread the fun!

🧠 Got an article or market take? Send it in—we’ll feature our favorites in an upcoming issue.

💬 Want your question featured on the next show? DM us on Instagram or reply to this newsletter.