By Tom Brookhart · November 24, 2025

There’s a moment every Porsche 911 enthusiast knows. 

Maybe it started with the dog-eared page you tore out of Road & Track, Car and Driver,  or a glossy photo pulled from a Porsche catalog you snagged at the local dealer. Or  maybe it was the poster above your childhood bed — that whale-tail silhouette frozen  mid-corner, promising speed, precision, and possibility. 

Whatever it was… it stuck. 

Years later, when you see that unmistakable shape in the wild — the upright headlights,  the humped deck-lid, the mechanical thrum of an air-cooled flat-six — something still  stirs inside you. 

In a way, it calls to you. 

It calls to your soul. 

It reminds you of the dreams you had in your youth — and, if you’re honest, the ones  you still have today. 

…and a decade ago, it felt attainable. 

Back then, the air-cooled 911 was the enthusiast’s loophole — a mechanical heirloom  you could buy for used-Honda money and keep alive with stubborn optimism and a set  of metric wrenches. 

But nostalgia has a way of smoothing over the rough parts. 

The truth is, the cars we remember from posters and magazine pages weren’t 40–50  years old. They weren’t running on decades of deferred maintenance, questionable  repairs, unreported accidents, or mystery engines with “rebuilt” stamped on a sales  listing. 

They were new. 

Or close to it. 

They were tight, torqued, sealed, tuned, and assembled by technicians who lived and  breathed these cars every single day.

Today’s air-cooled 911 landscape? 

Well… it’s different.

Somewhere around the early 2010s, when SCs and Carreras were hovering in the low to-mid teens, a lot of people jumped in. And who could blame them? These were  Porsche 911s that seemed — miraculously — within reach. 

And that influx of entry-level buyers created a trend almost no one talks about: A whole generation of 911s were maintained on tight budgets. 

Not maliciously. 

Not irresponsibly. 

Just… realistically. 

The dream was bought with what one could afford, and kept alive however possible. 

The problem is, those cost-saving decisions compound into years of small  compromises:

And then one day, the market flips — and suddenly that same budget-maintained car is  worth $60K. Or even $90K. Or more. 

A bath. 

A buff. 

Some tidy photos. 

And off it goes to Bring a Trailer. 

Air-cooled 911s are unbelievably resilient. They’ll run when they’re tired. They’ll run  when they’re leaking. They’ll run when their internals are begging for mercy. 

These engines don’t give up easily. 

That’s the blessing… and the curse. 

Because running becomes the standard. 

Not running the way they were designed. 

If your first experience with a 911 is a tired one, you start to believe the myths:

But Porsche never engineered these cars to feel sloppy, old, or crude. A properly sorted 911 — even one from the 1970s — is shockingly refined. 

The steering talks. 

The suspension works. 

The throttle responds with crisp, mechanical clarity. 

The engine pulls like it’s carved out of billet. 

And nothing leaks. 

The wonderful Porsche smell of oil and leather is there, but not overwhelming. 

Nothing feels like it’s on borrowed time. 

Most people have simply never driven one like that.

Here’s where the dream meets the invoice. 

A friend of mine bought a ’78 911 SC recently. 

Paid $60,000. 

Seven-out-of-ten paint. 

Very clean interior. 

Respectable presentation. 

And the big selling point — the one featured in the ad: 

“Rebuilt engine.”

That phrase alone hypnotizes new buyers. 

Mileage? Paint? Seats? Sure. 

But “rebuilt engine”? 

That shuts off the critical thinking switch. 

And like so many first-time buyers, he was focused on the shiny stuff:

What he didn’t see were the things that actually matter. 

I told him: 

“A properly sorted SC or Carrera 3.2 means a car with no excuses — running  exactly as Porsche intended.” 

Not a museum piece. 

Not a garage queen. 

Just a car that’s right. 

And being right isn’t about the big jobs alone — it’s the avalanche of little, invisible  things:

And then there are the big, expensive truths the ad never mentioned:

And on top of all that (and some more wallet-killers):

These aren’t optional jobs. 

They’re the inevitable cost of bringing a tired 911 back to factory behavior. And this isn’t really touching the cosmetics. 

And here’s the kicker: 

On the 300-mile drive home, the car was burning oil at a rate of 4 to 5 quarts per  thousand miles. 

Catastrophic consumption. 

And yet — astonishingly — the car made the trip. 

That’s the paradox of air-cooled 911s: 

They can be mechanically exhausted… 

and still run well enough to fool you.

And here’s the part nobody likes to admit: 

When you get emotional about these cars, logic leaves the room. 

You want it so badly that you start overlooking red flags. 

It’s the dream, remember? 

You start making excuses. 

You start believing the ad more than your own instincts. 

And if it’s your first air-cooled 911… 

You don’t even know what the red flags are. 

Words like: 

“Rebuilt” 

“Fresh engine” 

“Exemplary example” 

“Great leakdown numbers” 

These become magic spells. 

They pull you in. 

They make you believe you're buying the car from your childhood dreams. 

Emotion writes the check. 

Reality cashes it.

The dream of air-cooled Porsche ownership is real. 

The nostalgia is real. 

The soul is real. 

And when one of these cars is right — truly sorted, truly healthy — there’s nothing else  like it. 

The steering, the feedback, the sound, the smell, the mechanical honesty… it’s an  experience that borders on spiritual. 

A properly sorted 911 doesn’t just drive well — it connects with you in a way modern  cars never will.

But those feelings exist because Porsche built something exceptional, not because  these cars are simple, cheap, or forgiving of years of shortcuts. 

These cars are special. 

These cars are worth preserving. 

But getting one to drive the way Porsche intended takes real time, real work, and real  money. 

Not because they’re flawed — but because they’re old, valuable, and often  misunderstood. 

The hardest truth of all? 

Many of the air-cooled 911s you see for sale or on the road today do not drive the way  Porsche designed them to. 

Not because owners don’t care — but because most people have simply never  experienced one that’s been fully, properly brought back to its original standard. 

The goal of this series isn’t to scare anyone away. 

It’s to bring clarity where there’s confusion… and honesty where there’s myth. Because when you finally drive an air-cooled 911 that’s truly sorted? You understand exactly why these cars became legends. 

Stay tuned for Part II: The Iceberg Car — What’s Hiding Beneath.

— Tom Brookhart

🧠 Got an article or market take? Send it in—we’ll feature our favorites in an upcoming issue.

💬 Want your question featured on the next show? DM us on Instagram or reply to this newsletter.

By Paul Kramer · November 24, 2025

If you’ve ever looked at a Porsche and thought, “Yeah, but what if it came in the exact shade of my childhood BMX bike?” — congratulations, you’re Sonderwunsch material.

Most people think Porsche’s “Special Wish” program is just fancy paint and a leather-wrapped cupholder.  Wrong.

It’s Porsche whispering, “How weird do you want to get? We’ve seen things.”

Let’s talk about it.

Back in the day, Sonderwunsch was like an underground speakeasy for Porsche nerds:

It’s where Flachbau (slantnose) 930s came from.
It’s where colors like Rubystone, Mint Green, and that insane 80s Blue-Green unicorn paint were born.
It’s where Porsche said, “Sure, we’ll do that… it’ll just cost you.”

Modern Sonderwunsch is basically Porsche Classic and Porsche Exclusive Manufaktur having a baby raised on artistic freedom and German precision.

If you want:

Sonderwunsch will do it.

They’ll also politely judge you.
But they’ll still do it, within reason and taste.

Because nothing says “I take my obsessiveness seriously” like a car Porsche literally built just for you.

Sonderwunsch cars aren’t about status.
They’re about identity.

You’re not buying another 911.
You’re commissioning a piece of the factory.

It’s the closest most of us will ever get to feeling like a mildly eccentric billionaire or a rockstar… or both.

Every Sonderwunsch Porsche comes with a built-in bragging rights package:

Nobody tells these stories.
They perform them.

And rightfully so.

You bet.

Weird, rare, funky, bespoke Porsches are collector candy — because they’re not just cars, they’re time capsules of someone’s very specific (and sometimes questionable) taste.

But that’s the charm.
It’s personal.
It’s original.
And it’s a Porsche that literally nobody else has.

Try putting a price on that.

Sonderwunsch isn’t about showing off.
It’s about celebrating your inner car-nerd without apology.

It’s Porsche saying, “Give us your wild idea. We’ll make it look factory.”

So if you ever find yourself dreaming up the perfect Porsche in embarrassing detail…
Sonderwunsch isn’t a program.

It’s permission.

— Paul Kramer

🏁 The Full Throttle Talk Team

🎙️ Full Throttle Talk Podcast Plug: Tune in wherever you get your podcasts.