By Blair Smith · March 2, 2026

There’s no denying that Bring a Trailer has changed the enthusiast car world. For better…..and worse. I’ve bought 2 cars and sold 2 cars on the platform, with many bids in between.

Here’s my honest take.

When Bring a Trailer first gained traction, it felt like something special:

Private sellers listing cars they actually cared about.

These weren’t just inventory units. They were:

And while the platform has evolved, that spirit still mostly exists. You can still feel when a car has a story behind it, which is one of my favorite things about this hobby!

Before BaT, selling a niche enthusiast car could be painful:

BaT created real liquidity in a previously fragmented market.

Obscure wagons? Air-cooled jewels? Rad-era Japanese stuff?

There’s a national audience now. And they’re paying real money.

That’s a massive net positive.

Even if you never bid, BaT is an incredible valuation tool.

Want to know what that low-mile, slick-top E46 M3 in Imola Red actually sells for? It’s there.

Want to see how options impact price? It’s there.

Transparent sales history has reshaped how we think about values. For enthusiasts, that’s empowering.

Let’s be honest: half the fun is the comments section.

You’ll find:

For car junkies, it’s entertainment. It’s education. It’s an outlet.

We all regularly browse with zero intention of buying anything.

This is probably my biggest gripe.

As more dealers flood the platform, it starts to feel less like a community and more like inventory management.

The vibe shifts from:

to

It changes the energy and is the first thing I want to know – “Private seller” or “Dealer”.

A car doesn’t sell?

No problem. Relist it.

Didn’t sell again? Relist it.

Still didn’t sell? Let’s keep trying.

At some point, the market has spoken.

Personally, I’d love to see a rule:

If it fails once or twice, the next listing should be no reserve. Otherwise, it starts to feel like we’re trying to push pricing into existence instead of discovering it.

This seems to happen most frequently with BaT “Local Partners”, as if they’re the ones making the rules.

Early in my enthusiast life, I’d wire money for a car based on photos and vibes. What could go wrong?!

Now? Not so much.

The more cars you own, the more particular you become. You start noticing:

Buying sight unseen becomes harder the deeper you go down the rabbit hole.

And no comment section can replace a test drive.

BaT’s success has reshaped the landscape.

But there’s a trade-off:

Convenience is great.

Consolidation is complicated.

When everything flows through one or two major platforms, the ecosystem changes.

Bring a Trailer is one of the most influential forces in the modern enthusiast car market.

It’s:

But it’s also:

Like most things that scale, it gains power and loses intimacy at the same time.

I love Bring a Trailer.

I hope it will always be about the enthusiasts.....and their cars. 

Thanks,

— Blair Smith

🏁 The Full Throttle Talk Team

📩 Don’t keep Full Throttle Talk a secret—share it with a friend, family member, or colleague. Let’s spread the fun!

🧠 Got an article or market take? Send it in—we’ll feature our favorites in an upcoming issue.

💬 Want your question featured on the next show? DM us on Instagram or reply to this newsletter.